Vaisala updated its GLD360 lightning detection systems all over the world, on December 8, 2020.
This update reanalyzes the data collected by the network and corrects the propagation time of the electromagnetic wave for each sensor.
Based on our real time observations, it is possible to raise the alarm with a site in regard to the imminent approach of a storm so that the risk of lightning strikes on people and property can be mitigated.
The method used involves creating a monitoring area around the site and raising an alarm as soon as the initial lightning strikes are detected in this zone. The site is then informed of when the thunderstorm has ended and activity has stopped within this perimeter.
The ellipse is a statistical indicator based on the measurement errors made by the sensors.
To address divergent practices worldwide in the way that lightning density is determined, the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) deemed it necessary to establish a common standard in order to harmonise said practices.
IEC/NF EN 62858:2016 aims to establish common rules and identify reliable methods for the establishment of lightning statistics that serve as the basis for lightning risk analysis (LRA).
The video data and electric field recording campaign took place from 16 July to 6 October 2015. A total of 206 observations were recorded across France during 13 storm-chasing missions carried out by Temps d’Orages.
The Météorage network gives an estimate of the intensity of the arc current that flows through lightning strikes that are produced between clouds and the ground and those that remain in the air. This calculation is carried out by the central calculator in real time using the peak magnetic field amplitude measured by the sensors.
- Abstract (English) -
Lightning superbolts are the most powerful and rare lightning events with intense optical emission, first identified from space. Superbolt events occurred in 2010-2018 could be localized by extracting the high energy tail of the lightning stroke signals measured by the very low frequency ground stations of the World-Wide Lightning Location Network. Here, we report electromagnetic observations of superbolts from space using Van Allen Probes
satellite measurements, and ground measurements, and with two events measured both from ground and space. From burst-triggered measurements, we compute electric and magnetic power spectral density for very low frequency waves driven by superbolts, both on Earth and transmitted into space, demonstrating that superbolts transmit 10-1000 times more powerful very low frequency waves into space than typical strokes and revealing that their extreme nature is observed in space. We find several properties of superbolts that notably differ from most lightning flashes; a more symmetric first ground-wave peak due to a longer rise time, larger peak current, weaker decay of electromagnetic power density in space with distance, and a power mostly confined in the very low frequency range. Their signal is absent in space during day times and is received with a long-time delay on the Van Allen Probes. These results have implications for our understanding of lightning and superbolts, for ionospheremagnetosphere wave transmission, wave propagation in space, and remote sensing of extreme events.
- Abstract (English) -
Information about lightning properties is important in order to advance the current understanding of lightning, whereby the characteristics of ground strike points (GSPs) are in particular helpful to improving the risk estimation for lightning protection. Lightning properties of a total of 1174 negative downward lightning flashes are analyzed.
The high-speed video recordings are taken in different regions, including Austria, Brazil, South Africa and the USA, and are analyzed in terms of flash multiplicity, duration, interstroke intervals and ground strike point properties. According to our knowledge this is the first simultaneous analysis of GSP properties in different regions of the world applying a common methodology. Although the results vary among the data sets, the analysis reveals that a third of the flashes are single-stroke events, while the overall mean number of strokes per flash equals 3.67. From the video imagery an average of 1.56 GSPs per flash is derived, with about 60% of the multiple-stroke flashes striking the ground in more than one place. It follows that a ground contact point is struck 2.35 times on average. Multiple-stroke flashes last on average 371 ms, whereas the geometric mean (GM) interstroke interval value preceding strokes producing a new GSP is about 18% greater than the GM value preceding subsequent strokes following a pre-existing lightning channel. In addition, a positive correlation between the duration and multiplicity of the flash is presented. The characteristics of the subset of flashes exhibiting multiple GSPs is further examined.
It follows that strokes with a stroke order of 2 create a new GSP in 60% of the cases, while this percentage quickly drops for higher-order strokes. Further, the possibility of forming a new lightning channel to ground in terms of the number of strokes that conditioned the previous lightning channel shows that approximately 88% developed after the occurrence of only one stroke. Investigating the time intervals in the other 12% of the cases when two or more strokes re-used the previous lightning channel showed that the average interstroke time interval preceding a new lightning channel is found to be more than twice the time difference between strokes that follow the previous lightning channel.
Click here to see the PAPER (PART 1 - Observations)
CLICK HERE TO SEE THE PAPER (PART 2 - ALGORITHM VALIDATION)
IEC 62305-2 is the reference standard for lightning risk calculation. Its formulas are used by many other standards including electrical installation, photovoltaic systems and wind turbines. First standard has been published in 2006 but is based on IEC report dated 1995. In spite of this long experience there are still fields of improvements. The edition 2 of this standard appears as too complex for simple cases and too simple for complex cases. The complexity can be addressed by software also the paper concentrates on improvements for the most complex cases.
High rise structures or structures located on a top of a hill/mountain are presently covered by an environment factor Cd defined in IEC 62305-2. The maximum value 2 for this factor Cd seems to be too low. The new draft for wind turbine lightning protection standard is proposing other concept and values for this factor Cd. Recent experience has also shown that the risk for regular structures using this factor Cd may be underestimated and the shape of the terrain should be better described.
For Lightning Location Systems that don’t provide directly the lightning ground strike-point density Nsg, a safety margin should be applied to the flash ground density Ng even if the ratio between the two are not constant in places and in time.
Temporary activities with a duration of less than a year should be covered by the standards. There is a benefit to address the lightning density per month, but it is not suggested to use a shorter time window. Nsg is a mean value based on 10 years’ observation. It is suggested for more sensitive or riskier activities to consider the highest value for Nsg during these 10 years and not the mean value.
Soil resistivity is a key parameter for underground services. However, soil resistivity is very difficult to obtain on a large scale when a service can extend up to 1 km away from the structure.
Probabilities related to the use of Surge Protective Devices are currently confusing as it is only based on SPD withstand when an SPD can withstand and not protect equipment. What is important to protect are equipment and not SPDs. Pspd should include both the SPD withstand and the protection efficiency near sensitive equipment.
Losses is also another confusing parameter because it is mainly based on fire risk when the damages caused by lightning may not involve a fire. The concept of losses should be replaced by the frequency of damage that would allow to define the protection based on what is really needed associating damage scenarios to the frequency of damages.
The lightning data collected by Lightning Locating Systems operating in the Low Frequency range is of great interest in many end user applications. Because this data is derived from remote sensing measurements it suffers from inaccuracies depending on system technology and the effectiveness of the operations. To guarantee the reliability and homogeneity of the various lightning datasets made available on the market, the IEC 62858 standard requires a minimum level of performance for an LLS to be qualified and deliver reliable data. This document reviews the main performance parameters, the minimum requirements that must be achieved It is defined. by an LLS and introduce the lightning data structure and its relations with the natural lightning related electrical processes. The objective of this paper is to give end users that are not knowledgeable on LLS some information about the limitations of LLS and the different data that are made available.
- Abstract -
We examined the initial conditions leading to negative cloud-to-ground (-CG) flashes with a return stroke larger than 100 kA (absolute value), so called -CG<-100kA flashes. The dataset is made of 88 flashes observed during summer 2017 over Corsica in France by a Lightning Locating System (Météorage), a Lightning Mapping Array (SAETTA) and BLESKA, a broadband HF magnetic field analyzer. We found that -CG<-100kA flashes exhibited in average a vertical extent of 2730m and initiated at an altitude of 3720m, these values being far below those we recorded for -CG>-100kA flashes, respectively 3600m and 5350m. In addition, -CG<-100kA flashes presented a short delay of about 2ms between the first preliminary breakdown pulse and the return stroke. We concluded that -CG<-100kA flashes are mainly related to low base and top thunderclouds which combined with the elevated terrain in Corsica might enhance the vertical electric field and the electrical charges motion resulting in large return strokes. Finally, we noted that all the analyzed strokes were followed by a period ranging from 7ms to 98ms during which no VHF activity was detected by SAETTA, likely to be related to the continuing current phase.
- Abstract -
Météorage detected nearly 4.3 million lightning discharges in 2017 in France out of which 86% are intra-cloud (IC) pulses. Benefiting from a new flash grouping algorithm that combines both IC pulses and Cloud-to-Ground (CG) return strokes, we observed that 95% of the flashes exhibit in-cloud activity breaking down in 76% of IC flashes and 19% of CG flashes we termed hybrid (HY) flashes as they are made of both IC and CG Météorage records. Météorage network manages to detect as many as 2.1 IC pulses per flash in -IC flashes, 3.0 for +IC flashes, 3.6 IC pulses for -HY flashes and up to 5.0 IC pulses for +HY flashes. IC pulses recorded during HY flashes are often of the same polarity as the paired return strokes. A detailed analysis showed that these IC pulses occur mostly before the first return stroke, in average 72% of all HY flashes. They are also observed between subsequent strokes and after the last return stroke in respectively 48% and 57% of the flashes. We computed a median inter-pulse delay of 7 ms and of 14 ms for +HY and -HY flashes respectively, and a median separation time between IC pulses and first return stroke of 54 ms and 82 ms respectively. The comparison of these statistics with results found in literature on Preliminary Breakdown Pulses (PBP) and K-changes revealed that they are in good agreement despite a limitation on the IC pulse detection efficiency. We conclude that the IC pulses detected by Météorage are related to such in-cloud processes. The second part of this analysis used a total lightning dataset consisting of LF and VHF data collected respectively by Météorage and SAETTA, a LMA network deployed in Corsica. The analysis permitted to assess the IC pulses location accuracy by Météorage is around 3 km in average with 1.64 km median value with a mean DE of 56%. We found the DE in Corsica is depending on the vertical extent of the flashes that must exceed 2.6 km (median value) to be detected by Météorage. Surprisingly, despite the median vertical extend of CG flashes is 2.7 km, they are perfectly detected by Météorage (97 % CG flash DE against high speed video records).
- Abstract -
Météorage, the French National Lightning Locating System (LLS) operator, has developed the “Severe Thunderstorm Observation and Reporting Method” (STORM) aiming at detecting active thunderstorms and preventing severe weather based on VLF/LF total lightning data made of Cloud-To-Ground (CG) flashes and Cloud-To-Cloud discharges (CC).
In this study, the capability of STORM to first, identify and track lightning cells and second, to predict severe weather is estimated based on hail ground truth data collected in 2014 across France by the ANELFA [Dessens et al 2006].
- Abstract -
This work aimed at analysing the occurrence of Intense Cloud-to-Ground (ICG) in Western Europe, including a large part of maritime areas, defined as lightning flashes exhibiting at least one return stroke peak current larger than 200 kA based on lightning data collected by EUCLID between 2007 and 2016. As expected, the rate of ICG is low in average, about 0.18 % of the total Cloud-to-Ground (CG), but because of a pronounced seasonal trend it can increase up to 1.5% in winter. Around 70% of ICG occurring over the Atlantic Ocean and the Mediterranean Sea are of negative polarity whereas, in around the same proportion, they are positive over the continental regions. The geographical distribution of ICG shows a clear enhancement of ICG occurrences during winter time along coastal areas exhibiting elevated terrain, in northern Spain and western Italy and in Balkans. In these regions ICG are mainly located in land and surprisingly their polarity is negative on the contrary to the general trend stating most ICG are positive on the Continent. The discrepancies observed in the geographical, seasonal and polarity distributions are thought to be related to the different type of thunderstorms occurring across Europe and particularly oceanic and Mediterranean winter and continental deep-convective clouds. Finally, some high-density areas along Italian or Balkan coastlines can reach up to 0.45 ICG/km²/year, both polarities combined.
- Abstract -
Draft standard IEC 62793 deals with Thunderstorm Warning Systems (TWS). This standard introduces many definitions and deals with many technologies. The study concentrates on Lightning Location Systems (LLS) and local field mill detectors. Regarding LLS, the European lightning detection network is used as an example for determining its efficiency with respect to warnings of cloud-to-ground lightning in Western Europe using the definitions given by the standard. In terms of field experience, LLS have maintenance rules that are under responsibility of the LLS operator. But in case of local sensors such as field mill detectors it is crucial that maintenance is made by the user or a specialized company. Field experience in harsh environment shows that local sensor of the field mill type may give false warnings or at the opposite no warning if not properly maintained. The new draft standard IEC 62793 Ed. 1 addresses specifically tests on local sensors introduced to increase their withstanding against environment.
- Abstract -
This paper presents a performance analysis of the European lightning detection network (EUCLID) with respect to warnings of cloud-to-ground lightning in western Europe.
These warnings allow to prevent accidents due to thunderstorms electrical activity, and can be employed in several domains such as industry, utility networks, leisure activities, transport, civil protection, …
In these sectors, a reliable and efficient warning is considered as vital, according to the risk of human and assets losses.
Based on a standard configuration, we have evaluated the EUCLID warning system’s efficiency and obtained some convincing results with 96% of probability of detection (POD) and with a 20 minutes’ lead time in more than 80% of the cases. Upon conclusion of the study, these results were compared to some previous studies which had evaluated the electric field mills’ efficiency.
- Abstract -
Severe storms exhibit a common pattern consisting in a rapid increase of the total lightning rate (i.e. Cloud-to-Ground and Cloud-to-Cloud flashes) few to tenths of minutes in advance to heavy precipitation, hail or tornado. This “lightning jump” is an interesting feature for now-casting weather applications since it can help predicting severe weather occurrence with a sufficient lead time in most cases [Williams et al, 1999; Murphy and Demetriades 2005; Schultz et al, 2009].
Several algorithms have been developed to monitor lightning rate trends and detect the onset of the lightning jump on the basis of VFH lightning data [Gatlin and Goodman 2010]. Out of those algorithms, the “2σ configuration” has been statically validated on various thunderstorm types and is likely to be the most effective to use for operational usage [Schultz et al. 2014].
Météorage has design and developed a cell identification method using the DBSCAN algorithm [Ester et al. 1996] to cluster VLF/LF total lightning data consisting in Cloud-to-Ground and Cloud-toCloud flashes collected by the French National Lightning Locating System. In this algorithm so called STORM, every individual cell is then tracked and its characteristics (eg. position, direction of propagation, speed, area and number of flashes) are monitored all long the lifecycle. The analysis of the evolution of the total lightning flash rate by the “2σ configuration” lightning jump algorithm helps predicting severe weather occurrences and triggering warning messages.
This study aimed at determining the overall performances of STORM by comparing computed lightning cell and severe weather alerts against ground truth hail observations. This dataset consists of 248 valid hail reports collect in 2014 across France by the ANELFA, the national association for hail risk prevention [Dessens et al 2006]. Preliminary results show a clear seasonal dependency since winter storms are less likely to be detected by STORM because they produce few lightning. However, they are encouraging since a Probability of Detection of 80% is obtained for severe hailstorms producing hailstones with a diameter equal to or greater than 2.5cm. In addition, the mean Warning Lead Time is found to be about 15 min and reach 18 min for severe thunderstorms. Those results being consistent with those from similar studies [Schultz et al. 2009] it turns out the usage of VLF/LF lightning data are relevant for severe storms tracking and alerts.
Further work shall be carried out to optimize STORM settings in order the cell identification algorithm is improved. Comparison of VLF/LF lightning cells with radar and Lightning Mapping Array should help in tuning the overall performances and better understanding strengths and weaknesses of such a tool.
- Abstract -
The location accuracy is one of the important parameters characterizing the performance of a lightning location system. It is also one of the most difficult to determine as the actual location of the discharge being located must be accurately known to achieve a reliable assessment of the real error. Among all the measurement techniques which can be used to collect such ground truth data, none can cover large area preventing the estimation of the location accuracy at a regional or national scale. Trying to get around this limitation, Météorage has developed a method based on lightning ground strike point data collected by the French national lightning locating system computing the separation distances of return strokes identified as using the same attachment point on the ground. As a result, statistics on the relative location accuracy over the last 10 years of operation at the national scale are produced. In order to determine whether this data could be a proxy for the absolute location accuracy they are compared against systematic errors estimated in the vicinity of high elevation towers well known to attract or trigger lightning. If the study shows some discrepancies between relative and absolute errors at the beginning of the period, mainly due to technological upgrades in the system, it turns out both parameters fit nicely since 2010. This tending to demonstrate the relative errors estimated based on the ground strike point can be used as a good proxy for the absolute location errors estimate.
- Abstract -
Lightning detection provides always higher performance in R&D context. But the applications of lightning data in Meteorology and industrial safety requires a better understanding of the quality of the measures provided by detection networks. We will highlight the key drivers for this quality and how they can be assessed.
- Abstract -
In the lightning protection domain, the vulnerability of structures to lightning is commonly estimated by using the rolling sphere method (RSM). Moreover, this method is recommended in the International Standard IEC 62305-3. This is an electrogeometric model (EGM) which consists in rolling over the structure an imaginary sphere the radius of which depends on the estimated peak current of the lightning flash return stroke. The sphere center is considered as the location of the negative downward leader tip which propagates vertically to the ground. Thus all the surface contact points are considered to require protection, whilst the unaffected volumes are assumed to be protected. However, the major drawback is that this model does not take into account some aspects like the ground influence (ground conductivity and local field reinforcement), the upward leaders development and other climatic and geographic parameters.
In order to evaluate the lightning impact probability over a structure, we propose in this paper a 3D method based on the electrogeometric model application by mainly taking into account the upward leaders development. The structure profile is enhanced at locations where the reinforcement of the electrical field at the ground is the most important. Then, applying the rolling sphere method on this new profile, the surface generated by the different trajectories of the center of the modified rolling sphere is deduced and lightning impact probabilities are evaluated.
This new approach has been applied to the case of the observatory of the Pic du Midi de Bigorre in south of France where a lightning station is installed. So the numerical results are compared to the observations on site, to any experimental measurements and to the lightning detection network data.
- Abstract -
Orange and Meteorage have unified their skills to set up an experiment related to the lightning storms. It consists in measuring the current values when direct strokes hit the air termination system on two radio telecommunication towers and in addition to check the way it is distributed within the structure.
For Orange the results will be precious to contribute to the ITUT Standardization in order to optimize the engineering rules for the radio communication towers electromagnetic protection. For Meteorage the interest is to strengthen and validate the algorithms of the stormy activity geo-localization, knowing that for a given lightning stroke Orange has this information. The two experimental sites are located in the Rhône-Durance (France) area. Each one is equipped with a field mill to register the electrostatic field in an area of 15km around the site, 24h a day, and with a digital oscilloscope to which are connected four current transformers dedicated to the direct lightning stroke current, to the current flowing through the surge arrestors, to the electric line and to the grounding system. The control of both instrumentations is performed through the 3G network. The paper focuses on the main objectives of this experiment, the difficulties encountered for the installation of the measuring equipment and the solution which have been implemented to fix them. Then the outcomes of the experiment will be discussed with regard to the ongoing work in standardization.
- Abstract -
Lightning locating systems (LLS) can provide flash data derived from individual return stroke based on a flash grouping algorithm. However the latter considers negative cloudto-ground (CG) flashes striking the ground in a unique point represented by the location of the first return stroke. According to video observations flashes have often different ground strike points. This can be a limitation in some engineering applications like the lightning risk assessment where the actual number of ground contacts is an important parameter. To get around this limitation Météorage has developed an algorithm allowing the identification of the location of the ground strike points (GSP) based on a statistical clustering (‘k-means’) method. The effectiveness of this algorithm, using operational LLS data, is tested on a total of 227 negative CG flashes observed with high speed video cameras in Austria and in France, in 2012 and 2013 respectively. The comparison between GSP computation and video observations reveals a GSP detection efficiency (DE) of about 95%. In addition the algorithm is able to discriminate between strokes creating a new ground contact (NGC) or using a pre-existing channel (PEC) in 83% out of the 767 observed strokes. The analysis shows that the limitation of the model is highly depending on the DE and location accuracy (LA) of the LLS collecting the data. Nevertheless, the fairly good results obtained with the GSP identification algorithm permits to build from existing VLF/LF LLS lightning data a hierarchical interlocked data structure composed of chronological events starting with the flash as the root event which is composed of GSPs being containing themselves strokes. This new dataset describes in a more complete way some lightning parameters related to a flash (e.g. flash multiplicity and number of ground strike points per flash) and their individual relationship, giving room to the improvement of engineering and research applications.
- Abstract -
This paper deals with performance evaluation of the European lightning location system EUCLID in France during the HyMeX  Special Observation Period 1 (SOP1) in 2012. Beside other instruments a Lightning Mapping Array (HyLMA) and a mobile Video and Field Recording System (VFRS) was deployed in the south of France. The data of those independent systems are used to determine the performance of the EUCLID lightning location system (LLS) in terms of detection efficiency (DE) and location accuracy (LA) for both CG and IC flashes.
Based on VFRS records of 161 flashes, we determined a negative/positive flash DE of 90/87% and negative/positive strokes DE of 87/84%. The negative flash DE is quite low compared to the usual performance noticed on similar LLS because during two days of the VFRS measurements, where a significant amount of the negative flashes was recorded, a nearby sensor was out of order. The positive flash DE is low because the criteria to determine if a stroke was correctly detected by the operational LLS are quite strict. In fact only one positive stroke out of 56 strokes was not detected by the LLS.
The HyLMA data gave us the opportunity to objectively determine for the first time an intra-cloud (IC) DE for a network in Europe. We analyzed the IC-DE for so called isolated ICs. Isolated ICs are IC discharges which are not related to any cloud to ground stroke. For one isolated storm we found a surprisingly good IC-DE of 47%. Unfortunately we also realized that the LA of the IC discharges is not as good as for CG strokes.
- Abstract -
This paper is intended to be an introduction to the capabilities of lightning detection networks and to provide guidelines to understand the type and quality of data that can be expected from those measurement systems. It first introduces the principle of lightning detection then covers the performances and limitations of the various technologies in use. A review of the knowledge on the lightning phenomenon gained through the analysis of the data provided by those networks in then presented. Typical values for lightning parameters are finally reviewed.
- Abstract -
Between May and October 2013 (period of sustained thunderstorm activity in France), several cloud-to-ground lightning flashes have been observed in Paris area with a high-speed video camera (14000 frames per second). The localization and the polarity of the recorded cloud-to-ground flashes have been obtained from the French lightning detection network Météorage which is equipped with the same low frequency sensors used by the US NLDN. In this paper we focused on 7 events (3 positive cloud-to-ground lightning flashes and 4 negative cloud-to-ground lightning flashes). The propagation velocity of the leaders and its temporal evolution have been estimated; the evolution of branching of the negative leaders have been observed during the propagation of the channel which get connected to ground and initiate the first return stroke. One aim of this preliminary study is to emphasize the differences between the characteristics of the positive and of the negative leaders.
- Abstract -
In this paper, we analyze the correlation between altitude and lightning stroke density in the area around Pic du Midi in France. The lightning stroke density was found to increase linearly over the altitude range 600-2700 m in the Pyrenees and remained constant in the plains. The relation between the lightning stroke amplitude and the altitude was also analyzed. The mean and maximum values of lightning return stroke peak currents observed over the altitude range 0-3000 m were found to remain constant within the area of study.
- Abstract -
In this paper we present a performance analysis of the European lightning location system EUCLID in terms of location accuracy (LA), detection efficiency (DE) and peak current estimation. The performance analysis is based on ground truth data from direct lightning current measurements at the Gaisberg Tower (GBT) and data from E-field and video recordings. The E-field and video recordings were taken in three different regions in Europe, in Austria, in Belgium and in France. The analysis shows a significant improvement of the LA over the past seven years. Currently the median LA is in the range of 100 m. The observed DE in Austria and Belgium is similar yet a slightly lower value is found in France because during the measurement period in France a nearby lightning location sensor was out of order. The accuracy of the lightning location system (LLS) peak current estimation for subsequent strokes is reasonable keeping in mind that the LLS estimated peak currents are determined from the radiated electromagnetic fields assuming a constant return stroke speed.
The results presented in this paper can be used to estimate the performance of the EUCLID network for regions with similar sensor baseline and sensor technology.
- Abstract -
Most of lightning statistics used by the lightning protection community are derived from lightning locating systems. Such systems collect flash data over large regions and during long period of time. In their life, those systems are likely to undergo several major changes as the state of the art in remote sensing techniques improves leading to some impacts on the data. In addition the flash data measured by lightning locating systems underestimate the actual lightning risk since it accounts only for one ground contact per flash that is well known nowadays not correct. Then the different evolutions in observing systems and underestimation introduced by flash data must be addressed and compensated in order to give a more accurate and relevant information for lightning risk assessment.
The French national lightning locating system operated by Météorage, has collected more than 20 years of lightning data all over the country. This system is no exception since from its inception several major changes, in either technology or system settings, have significantly modified the lightning detection performances affecting the homogeneity of the data and the relevancy of the GFD statistics.
The work presented in this paper is based on this long duration French dataset. It attempts to define a method which comes around the inhomogeneity introduced by lightning detection performance evolutions and suggests the use of the flash ground contacts multiplicity instead of flash data only. To achieve this goal the cumulative peak current distribution method developed by the CIGRE task force C404 is used to determine the compensation factors to correct the statistics for detection efficiency effect. In addition, it is suggested the use of ground contacts data instead of flash data for lightning risk statistics. This parameter is derived from the lightning data collected in France on 2011 with a program developed by Météorage based on a clustering algorithm so called ‘k-means’.
The method suffers from some necessary assumptions depending on the Météorage’s LLS history and operational background, but the final new ground contacts density parameter derived from the longest observation period available in France looks more realistic and reliable. This work is a first attempt that must be extended in the future to compute high spatial resolution statistics supporting new applications for lightning risk assessment.
- Abstract -
The lightning protection standards recommend the use of the lightning ground flash density (GFD) for the risk assessment. Nowadays the national lightning location systems (LLS) can provide the lightning protection community with high spatial resolution GFD data. However these systems generally underestimate the GFD since the multiple ground contacts in flashes are not discriminated and then not taken into account in the flash density calculation.
The recent improvement in the location accuracy of the French National LLS, so called Meteorage, in 2011 was estimated with the pre-existing channel method developed by Cummins et al (2010). The global location accuracy was found to be better than 150m in accordance with Honna et al (2011). Therefore it seems possible to identify the different ground contacts in flashes based on strokes separation distances, since several video records studies showed the distance between ground contacts in flashes ranges from 0.3 to 7.3 km (Thottappillil et al (1992), Stall et al (2009)).
A statistical clustering method based on the so called “k-means analysis”, was developed to spatially partition the closest subsequent strokes of a flash in one or several clusters whose centroïds spot the ground contacts. To check the efficiency of the clustering method, a qualitative analysis was run on two LLS flash dataset previously correlated with video records in USA (Az) and Austria. For each individual flash, the number of ground contacts given by the clustering analysis was compared to the corresponding flash video observations as truth reference: the correlation rate for flashes having the same number of ground contacts range from 72% to 82% depending on the LLS stroke locations accuracy.
This encouraging result shows the capacity of the clustering method to identify ground contacts information from the Météorage’s flash data observations. A dataset of 8081 cloud-to-ground negative lightning flashes collected by Météorage during the summer in 2011 was analyzed with this method, which shows 47% of negative flashes are made of two or more ground contacts with an average number of contacts per flash around 1.74. The median separation distance between contacts is found to be 2.2 km. All these results are in good agreement with several video observations analysis (Rakov et al (1990), Saba et al (2006)).
Finally, the identification of ground contacts in flashes provided a way to estimate the relative stroke location accuracy in a better way than the PEC method since it produces a larger strokes dataset. The previous results could be confirmed as the maximum relative location error is about 110 meters.
- Abstract -
An experimental site devoted to the study of direct lightning impacts to lightning rods has been selected at the top of the Pic du Midi in the French Pyrénées. This site offers the exceptional opportunity of investigating lightning strokes to a complex structure of limited extension, intermediate between a large building at moderate altitude and a high-elevated structure such like the well-known instrumented telecommunication towers (Gaisberg, Peissenberg, Säntis or CN Tower). At the Pic du Midi, the famous astronomical Observatory offers an unique scientific environment for lightning observations (sprites, Météorage) in collaboration with astronomers.
Among various experiments, we will devote this paper to that installed at the top of the so-called DIMM platform. Several scientific sensors are here installed, such like measurements of lightning current, electric field, highspeed video and related recordings. This will enable to characterize both lightning attachment to an instrumented rod and lightning detection network efficiency at high altitude (about 2,900 m).
- Abstract -
This paper presents existing lightning data services that can be use as part of a lightning prevention approach and the result of a study of the use of lightning data services by industrial users. The study takes into account the reasons for choosing a lightning prevention approach, the benefits of this approach and its success factors.
- Abstract - (French)
La première mesure du foudroiement sur un territoire a été le niveau kéraunique, « nombre de jour où l’on a entendu le tonnerre », relevé par des observateurs humains. L’apparition des réseaux de détection foudre, à partir des années 70, a permis d’obtenir une information continue sur la localisation et les caractéristiques des coups de foudre. Les informations fournies par ces réseaux permettent de calculer le nombre de jour où un orage a frappé un lieu donné. D’autres informations peuvent aussi être calculées à partir de ces réseaux comme la densité de foudroiement (Nombre d’impact par an et par km²) qui permet de comparer la violence des orages en divers points, ou le calcul de l’intensité électrique de chaque impact. Cette étude présentera ces informations, l’évolution de leur précision, et l’utilisation qui en est faite.
- Abstract -
It is well known that a lightning detection network is able to record lightning activity. Among such networks, those using IMPACT technology are supposed to detect about 90 to 95% of cloud-toground flashes with peak current greater than 15 kA, with an average location accuracy of 500 m. One important question is to understand why some of the flashes are apparently not detected and to make clear how does the network groups into flashes the detected and located strokes.
A long duration thunderstorm has been studied by means of video photography and results are compared to data collected by the French detection and location network, the so called « Météorage network». This will allow us to evaluate what is the flash detection efficiency of the network and what are the limitations of direct observations.
In practice, every cloud-to-ground flash has been detected by at least one sensor. However, as we need at least two sensors to compute the flash location, such CG flash are not taken into account in data provided by the network. Moreover, data exhibits CG flashes with multiple polarity restrikes and sometimes the same observed CG flash appears several times in data. At last, it appears that some CG flashes are detected by a very large number of sensors although their peak intensity are lower than 30 kA. It is one of the goals of the present paper to deal with these observations.
Discussion about the total flash duration as compared with apparently observed flash lifetime will be opened. In some rare cases, estimation of the lightning location accuracy will be given.
- Abstract - (French)
La détection des orages est devenue au cours des dernières années un enjeu considérable pour l'ensemble des pays industrialisés. Ainsi de nombreux systèmes ont été développés à des fins d'étude, de prévision et de protection. Bien que diverses techniques existent pour détecter les orages, les systèmes de localisation des éclairs sont les plus utilisés dans le monde. Ils reposent sur la détection des signaux électromagnétiques générés par les éclairs. Les progrès réalisés dans le domaine spatial permettent d'envisager sérieusement de surveiller les orages à grande échelle depuis l'espace.
Ce document présente les différentes techniques mises en œuvre dans les systèmes de détection des orages.